Do shark culls keep people safe in the ocean? Here’s what the science says

Live updates

1. 1d ago

   Sydney shark attacks spark cull debate as beaches reopen under heavy patrols

   A critical injury in a recent Sydney shark attack has heightened fears among swimmers and reignited debate over culling as a safety measure. Beaches remain under heightened patrol, while scientists question the effectiveness of culls in reducing attacks. The incident has left a 35-year-old woman critically injured, and lifeguards intervened to save her. Public sentiment is shifting, with regular swimmers reporting increased caution after the attack.

   What's confirmed:

   • A 35-year-old woman suffered critical injuries in a shark attack off Sydney’s beach, requiring lifeguards to pull her onto a paddleboard for rescue.
   • Sydney beaches have reopened but are now under heavy patrols following the attack, though no official cull announcement has been made.
   • Local swimmers and regulars at Coogee Beach report heightened anxiety, with some reconsidering swimming due to the attack’s severity and shock value.
   • Scientific consensus remains divided on whether shark culls effectively reduce human attacks, with ongoing debate among experts.

   Still unconfirmed:

   • The attack victim is described as a 'loving' mom and teacher, though no official confirmation of her identity or condition beyond critical injury has been independently verified.
   • Some reports suggest the attack occurred 'like a horror movie,' but no firsthand visual or detailed accounts have been cross-verified.
   confidence 95%